Popular
Chocolate Chip Brownie (9pc)
Rich, fudgy chocolate chip brownies baked fresh and cut into shareable squares.
$8.99200 cal
4 ITEMS · $7.99-$9.99
Papa John's Desserts Menu & Prices
Finish the meal sweet with Chocolate Chip Brownies, Cinnamon Pull-Aparts, and warm Chocolate Chip Cookies.
All 4 desserts on the current menu, cheapest first. Papa John's stores are mostly franchised, so treat these as typical US prices rather than one national list.
Papa John's Desserts Prices
| Item | Calories | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Cinnamon Pull-Aparts (10pc)per piece | 190 cal | $7.99 |
| Chocolate Chip Brownie (9pc)Popularper piece | 200 cal | $8.99 |
| Double Chocolate Chip Brownie (9pc)per piece | 210 cal | $9.49 |
| Chocolate Chip Cookie (Large, serves 6)Popularper piece | 220 cal | $9.99 |
Prices checked August 2026. Delivery orders and third-party apps run higher than the carryout prices listed here.
What Each Dessert Looks Like
The same items with photos, descriptions and calorie counts.
Cinnamon Pull-Aparts (10pc)
Warm, soft dough pieces coated in cinnamon sugar with sweet icing for dipping.
$7.99190 cal
Popular
Chocolate Chip Cookie (Large, serves 6)
A giant, warm chocolate chip cookie baked fresh, perfect for sharing.
$9.99220 cal
Double Chocolate Chip Brownie (9pc)
Extra-chocolatey brownies loaded with chocolate chips and a fudgy center.
$9.49210 cal
About Papa John's Desserts
Finish the meal sweet with Chocolate Chip Brownies, Cinnamon Pull-Aparts, and warm Chocolate Chip Cookies.
Prices run $7.99 to $9.99 across 4 options, averaging around $9.12. Papa John's stores are mostly franchised so the exact figure moves a little by location, and carryout matches the listed price more closely than delivery does once fees land.
Papa John's Dessert Prices
Four desserts, all built to share, priced from $7.99 to $9.99. Cinnamon Pull-Aparts open the section at $7.99 for ten pieces and the Large Chocolate Chip Cookie closes it at $9.99.
The two brownies sit in the middle. Chocolate Chip is $8.99 and Double Chocolate Chip is fifty cents more at $9.49, both cut into nine pieces.
Pieces per Dollar
Cinnamon Pull-Aparts give you the most for the money - ten pieces at $7.99, which is eighty cents each and the lowest per-piece figure in the section. The brownies come to about a dollar a piece.
The cookie is listed as serving six and costs $9.99, so it works out around $1.67 a portion. It is the most expensive way to end the meal, though it is also the only one that arrives as a single warm thing rather than a tray of squares.
Calories and Ordering Ahead
Every figure in the table is per piece, not per box. Pull-Aparts are 190, the plain brownie 200, the double chocolate 210, and the cookie 220 a portion. A whole tray of brownies is around 1,800 calories.
Desserts bake to order at most stores, which is why they occasionally arrive after the pizza rather than with it. If you are ordering for a group and want everything hot at once, adding the dessert at the start of a quiet afternoon works better than at eight on a Friday.
Cheapest and Most Expensive
The least you can spend here is $7.99 on the Cinnamon Pull-Aparts (10pc). The most is $9.99 for the Chocolate Chip Cookie (Large, serves 6), which puts the average around $9.12.
Whether you're comparing sizes, checking calorie counts, or just deciding what to add to an order, the table and photos above cover every desserts option in one place, so there is nothing else to click through. For allergen details across the whole menu, see the allergen and calorie guide.
Desserts FAQs
From $7.99 for Cinnamon Pull-Aparts to $9.99 for the Large Chocolate Chip Cookie. The brownies are $8.99 and $9.49.